If you can find my shipment of rum and return it to me, then I can prove to MacKinley that Kalimdor's booze beats the dirt out of Booty Bay!
Did you find my shipment of rum, <name>?
Great, thanks for the shipment! Now MacKinley and I can finally settle our wager.
- 5550 XP
Go to the walled pirate town in Lost Rigger Cove. Stoley's rum is stashed in some boxes on the top floor of the northwestern house.