It's not working, <lad or lass>. I cannot give it enough heat... the materials will not be properly tempered.
You know, the Fel Reavers used by the Burning Legion are powered by a scalding core of fel fire - it burns much hotter than normal fire.
If you could find enough people to take one down, you could heat the mold in the insides of the fallen reaver. Beware, <Class>, those fel reavers pack quite a punch.
+350 reputation with Honor Hold
15800 XP (9 48 al level 70)
Quest progression Edit
You don't need to kill the Fel Reaver. Even if you were not in the party killing it, you can still use the quest item on the remains.